Baseball33% of finished draftsHighest score91.5Drafts2Perfect seasons1Perfect pick rateBoard-best choicesNormal75%9/12 picksBlind—No judged picks
Basketball33% of finished draftsHighest score94.2Drafts2Perfect seasons1Perfect pick rateBoard-best choicesNormal70%7/10 picksBlind—No judged picks
Hockey33% of finished draftsHighest score91.9Drafts2Perfect pick rateBoard-best choicesNormal46%11/24 picksBlind—No judged picks
Baseball15 completed13Hall / legendHall / legend rate87%Best peak100Titles28MVP honors18Records0Best earnings$220MLongest career17 seasons
Basketball6 completed5Hall / legendHall / legend rate83%Best peak100Titles8MVP honors8Records0Best earnings$239MLongest career17 seasons
Hockey4 completed4Hall / legendHall / legend rate100%Best peak100Titles10MVP honors9Records0Best earnings$207MLongest career17 seasons
01Baseball33%of boardsERA1980-89New York2/6BOARDS2PICKS3%SHARE2PLAYERS2/6BOARDS2PICKS3%SHARE2PLAYERSPennant winners ’81Best year: 103–59 (’80)Drafted coreDon Mattingly1B · '86Rickey HendersonCF · '85
02Baseball33%of boardsERA1940-49St. Louis2/6BOARDS2PICKS3%SHARE2PLAYERS2/6BOARDS2PICKS3%SHARE2PLAYERSWon the World Series ’42, ’44, ’46Pennant winners ’43Drafted coreJohnny Mize1B · '40Mort CooperSP · '42
03Baseball17%of boardsERA1920-29St. Louis1/6BOARDS1PICKS2%SHARE1PLAYERS1/6BOARDS1PICKS2%SHARE1PLAYERSWon the World Series ’26Pennant winners ’28Drafted coreRogers Hornsby2B · '22
01Baseball17%1 pick2B'22★Rogers HornsbySt. Louis 1920-29Triple Crown.401AVG42HR152RBI1.181OPS.459OBP.722SLG141R17SB.401AVG42HR152RBI1.181OPS.459OBP.722SLG141R17SBTriple Crown
02Baseball17%1 pickCF'85★Rickey HendersonNew York 1980-89All-Star ×5.314AVG24HR72RBI.934OPS.419OBP.516SLG146R80SB.314AVG24HR72RBI.934OPS.419OBP.516SLG146R80SBAll-Star ×5
03Baseball17%1 pickSP'44★Satchel PaigeKansas City 1940-48All-Star ×61.01ERA0.91WHIP105K6W98IP16GS6CG3SHO1.01ERA0.91WHIP105K6W98IP16GS6CG3SHOAll-Star ×6
04Baseball17%1 pickCF'20★Edd RoushCincinnati 1920-291× World Series.339AVG4HR90RBI.839OPS.386OBP.453SLG81R36SB.339AVG4HR90RBI.839OPS.386OBP.453SLG81R36SB1× World Series